Carey – 10 appearances (7-9) – 2011, 2009, 2008, 2007, 2003, 2001, 2000, 1994 (State Semifinalist), 1993, 1975 (State Champion)
Fostoria St. Wendelin – 5 appearances (5-5) 1990, 1987, 1986, 1982 (State Runner-Up), 1976 (State Semifinalist)
Fremont St. Joseph Central Catholic – 11 appearances (5-11) – 2010, 2009, 1997, 1996, 1992, 1990, 1989, 1988, 1985, 1978 (State Semifinalist), 1974 (State Runner-Up)
Hopewell-Loudon – 10 appearances (15-10) – 2011, 2009, 2008 (State Runner-Up), 2007 (State Runner-Up), 2006, 2005 (State Semifinalist), 2004, 2003, 2002, 1996
Mohawk – 10 appearances (5-10) – 2010, 2006, 2005, 2004, 2003, 2002, 2001, 2000, 1999, 1985
North Baltimore – 1 appearance (0-1) – 1995
Seneca East – 3 appearances (0-3) – 2004, 1992, 1985
Tiffin Calvert – 10 appearances (15-8) – 2011, 2002, 2001, 2000, 1999, 1998 (State Semifinalist), 1986, 1981 (State Champion), 1980 (State Champion), 1979
2011
Calvert (1-1)
Carey (0-1)
Hopewell-Loudon (0-1)
2010
Mohawk (1-1)
St. Joseph Central Catholic (0-1)
2009
Carey (1-1)
Hopewell-Loudon (1-1)
St. Joseph Central Catholic (0-1)
2008
Hopewell-Loudon (4-1) DVI State Runner-Up
Carey (1-1)
2007
Hopewell-Loudon (4-1) DVI State Runner-Up
Carey (0-1)
2006
Hopewell-Loudon (2-1)
Mohawk (0-1)
2005
Hopewell-Loudon (2-1)
Mohawk (0-1)
2004
Hopewell-Loudon (1-1)
Seneca East (0-1)
Mohawk (0-1)
2003
Carey (1-1)
Hopewell-Loudon (0-1)
Mohawk (0-1)
2002
Calvert (2-1)
Mohawk (1-1)
Hopewell-Loudon (0-1)
2001
Calvert (1-1)
Carey (0-1)
Mohawk (0-1)
2000
Carey (0-1)
Calvert (0-1)
Mohawk (0-1)
1999
Calvert (2-1)
Mohawk (2-1)
1998
Calvert (2-1)
1997
St. Joseph Central Catholic (1-1)
1996
St. Joseph Central Catholic (0-1)
Hopewell-Loudon (0-1)
1995
North Baltimore (0-1)
1994
Carey (2-1)
1993
Carey (0-1)
1992
St. Joseph Central Catholic (1-1)
Seneca East (0-1)
1991
none
1990
St. Joseph Central Catholic (1-1)
St. Wendelin (0-1)
1989
St. Joseph Central Catholic (0-1)
1988
St. Joseph Central Catholic (0-1)
1987
St. Wendelin (0-1)
1986
Calvert (1-1)
St. Wendelin (0-1)
